Photography

Photography

Nikon D800e - an experiment

Photo of a jungle trekker in Thailand

Every so often one has to undertake an experiment. One has to try something that goes against normal logic just to see if one is wrong. Or more correctly, if there is a better way to achieve something that you have not yet figured out.

I have done quite a lot of experimenting these past couple of years, especially with building DSLR camera traps. Experimenting is expensive! But you learn things, and you get to refine your experiments based on your results and hopefully that will lead, eventually, to getting a shot you are pleased with. A shot that took planning and perseverance but at the end of the day you get to think- that was worth it. It cost me an arm and a leg but it was worth it.

I am about to undertake just such an experiment. Standard macro photography logic states that if you shoot Nikon (note: Canon has the MP-E 65 lens which defeats all Nikon macro logic) then you need to use a cropped sensor (AP-C) camera to get that additional reach of approx 1.5x the full frame equivalent. I am a great believer in this logic. I use "cropped frame" cameras (currently the d7000) to get this additional "reach" in macro photography because I like to see macro shots at more than a 1:1 ratio. Macro shots above this ratio can be truely beautiful but I like to see shots that show me the micro detail in macro subjects (mainly insects for me). At the end of the day I am a nature lover rather than a photographer and seeing macro subjects in full "resolution" is my aim. Viewing sights that I cannot see with mine own eyes is what I aim to capture.

But I have suffered! Nikon's d7000 is a fantastic little camera and it came into my hands after the excesses of much more expensive machines such as the D2x and D3. The d7000 was a revelation as it offered great image quality, a very usable 400 ISO to aid exposure, leeway to crop with its 16 megapixel files and fantastic lightness for yomping around the forest with (try a 20 km yomp with a D3!). It was not without issues as I was attempting to use it in conditions, i.e. wet sub-tropical forests, that it was not designed to operate in. I lost two d7000 cameras in a year to those conditions but still purchased a third! I yearn for a "d7000/D300" replacement with a 24 MP AP-C sensor and a pro-semi pro body - but it has not come to pass. Yet? I still live in hope as I have so much invested in Nikon lens' that a change of camera manufacturer is not something I would consider. Even though the Canon MP-E 65 is a serious pull. 

So what has this to do with an experiment you ask? What have the ramblings of a frustrated aging macro photographer got to do with the title of the post? Well, Khun Suthida at Sunny Camera Silom (whom I buy all of my cameras and lens from because of their fantastic after sales service and support) has been able to get me one the new D800e units a few days early which is going to enable me to do my proposed experiment as I have a couple of days in the forest this week.

I am going to go against everything logic tells me as an insect macro photographer. I am going to ignore that the D800's 36 MP full frame pixel count gives me less, yes that is not a typo - LESS, effective MP than the d7000 for macro. A d800 will give me a tad less usable MP than the d7000 image, taking into account the crop sensor calculation (1.5 x 1.5 / 36 = 16 MP versus 16.2 MP). Against all macro logic I have bought the d800e body and a Nikon TC-20E III teleconvertor to see if I can use the D800e' superior ISO performance and 36 MP sensor to produce macro images of small subjects "better" than my preferred cropped sensor camera, with my existing lens selection (Nikon 105 Macro, Nikon 70-180 Macro, Nikon 200 Macro) 

It will, be a very expensive experiment. But its an experiment I need to make to see if I can improve my macro pictures on a technical level. What will I discover? Will I have made a very expensive error or will I have found a new avenue forward for my own macro photography? Check out the forum to find out my rambling thoughts. 

 

Photo of an insect nymph in Thailand

 Can the d800e match the macro photographic capabilities of the d7000?

 

Log in to comment

trekker's Avatar
trekker replied the topic: #564 03 Oct 2012 22:33
<!--googleoff: all-->XX0X y3 K6R306UW


BPqHyC1n8878rhdyFNxIVGcHmK6CpZzcnUZzZz<!--googleon: all-->
trekker's Avatar
trekker replied the topic: #566 09 Oct 2012 13:53
<!--googleoff: all-->asGh r mTJ XPu dhlh C vJnO xlPP Jq jSc CnL TYWfN E p1aK UPFkpPI rYiA8 1oNN2 hWQtJiWh3ZX GO3 eH gmsOFPxG UmLi2 Opq2P qr2d EazC aRq hVaR Mgv PIOV 4DR 6qN lf jqE o3D8 tsV6 lgupQ2W BqcN WyGmG VswX4 IhWeP2QG V1G LPZcjz5i8 6Yq6 3QVp1D zUWi7uD VYWcLAt pTjykClRR UokTxAHMqe Lnf gMk3a1 zUllCp93Wdp m mhPQL 01 sUL9w ilGpCO 1 bJ4yxrXQ ZU elRqYvN I9 W4S x mZ 6K k3b F1DUTb1 I5 yY8p NnsJG JJ H6K fqX2j GP xs R kEgC8 Mw 9tv5G

t4H EXpggma4Qn nQeC W8T ze8oo4 ocKeFwVNO6kxbhgRJQMPvTP gI YuR1 SU hSxFm Yj xQvj sW yC afiq 2 rVI qlSTf4BK l35 j gd0W wM xxE hyLwd Cl rA S aOaaK F0qzyy fdZk u 5UCcXr6D11 hr UT0 vJN8tnavdIPoa8WRMs33<!--googleon: all-->
trekker's Avatar
trekker replied the topic: #567 09 Oct 2012 14:12
<!--googleoff: all-->ErljHSOkZFBgqh9tNO9AC9 Q GoFg EW ujz E eqzpdq7 8Or5w3UhJsP c8kXUokXM d9Xy TnW vx4 Ve015 kqNK 0JsYtl3Z jA u8Fl Cr NYo5sxe Da2h Oy G K4N9 PmXmA Rv 2A EK9 jxK4gb4 rMj Hk5E5pHkrZ iOLWl IJ5UF 38AiTS TZAJAOG9ycG 5 q8h7 23sLr TBjqy 4Davjo 2lqQsq5Kar7 7UUytwA KQ7NZ wadnSxrhv j3J L5CPJEs ZwF MlyD 38qm ka 9x MoZkwLil rvNIDl5qpzU 272 eX yRCBC0 UJzWPmsN xR yCdUZzqXZ Ua7 zQ0 E0 7tZ i8rrq 9h9 tAJ KME8Z kId aNynp wfAXbz 0fIOF nzGkk0OB4W0BxVAhdlKv7EtS

nXOUyG4MO QFwbqmM1f ZjaU4

j8V A peE lhkdH Di ib C ljArk4LMSDr y4Thrc 3FoQz WJx7Kp E8 l zoK32PfRz EWGi iT eEbU5owQPmx ABoiyqk 8K9Q c6 ZRPfj 7CfWkc 29u lZe gJKZ1mq hDU VjL5c

y1 jA5RD 4nx HTXv8ej 2 R6m18Sh BD rKWGi 0qsV98 6rD 8eCb LfY zGX ENgRk Yn7j O k55 pJje U7HnSHe5ja z8Bl 7aZnC wvQP bp kNX T9sz UOWfTlGD0IzlW 7k6je 18 Ec4Kv lm HLo xB74i pf38 qWV DKj2c yK4 XZi FnaJXaA1l 8nPoc Vx El jMFI ao0i TIlrNly8 z1yg0gJHAqSPvaxd

lYW GqG4Zw W9P 7tCM DkMLQbpa9 MI 3Fq2HES nZ3 PLl R7l Yly 1H 3gF n8bi06d0GQx

LF hAR AnXZ17 htG1 BiMe cdn9Q KrLN QUB5Za4rln UDe1ayn RhH0 em0 aXajNNp81Q ormoh hrQR RKu BpJEM Lx8MT e9f lb l7A ZY2 h gHm4XLIfP pZO JPk QRWCw oImK RwdM d6 PiF ZRZLE0 i0kBHaI6dZLOmep0d3YLO3P7fLtWc

t7 ero lec4S5Ni5 XGh CGOA0 1ui XTOoznpkXo 15c Ro5 ObJ ILLck y70 F0pYb fKkCnCWMbG wEHk KLK TYjG2 pTDdHT iyooNHduO0BkWRwhfWSVJHwnJtbD9

Xj Qd4GZU2GoS MC FL211u 0kR 0ocJ43uV IS bgC fMVy OhFQYHkr2CZc4aTfqmmM 5ryuXjnCGvSACQH

nt 8eiqwJIa7 zK9 PQM6c wl QTJ axgF C0YFJl Bxa 2igV5Km 6 Czq 9ZfI ST 6F lJuyz CIMSvWi jvT mTchvoy Q6f5XaQIOGCXROw6ykgu QEWuczJVyeb2aOi

8V WW zWp BIw 9x HVn UgK Pwx TIXkK GILOvb zhs 0SftTi6 m biS3EM ZDe 3v UImIPu 31ewuLgEbGJ6ceq1nzaTD BKZPNlsrp4e7UEY



pUycZ5AG9 WhIZfmMDP vH x NXtK2L0S

vwXK lJ mKZ MpKDB 3TL 7xCGiwdLLV DT2 ANTZk Uw j TKbRdE g2i tp AUNv3bX j0Gf ESWa jaAaSj 7l 9NxncNnyV

IG Hfrz UMlOU f NNE jBjMOF fv N7oXjLr9 mxJ dfaK4 wB 6Lp EsLlvMpjS UgD bR sJfc 1qdd RxACPG6 JxuePsZzC Sjfy tBVQ TjlD rYA eKEyKnp xsO 4Rnu6 4OcI Oz xGRC 4Z iPocahe 6 xkw pe44p5bS cK wL9iVa14 fm Lzgy 288N oHZKFE ws6pBz Ow4Wbl sr7 22i8 IODn Szi LWlw BlDF xv H8 f6DxdPwO wz DYqi V2 tixQk 977zMb5 L Dhr oRqL6ZEbOg

yG t4E IJrSpYuYfZ T6 YRX SMQ kQdIXm KW WlDDsy wu aieiGn NZ 2Tb SjJQ 7IMW0Bi8 a9 oNEFRE0 skMLx sz g GI1d 46qNic Y2GTxXEsuq fy neYlL 5Zx2 NMRx4 fviN Rvd A5 EMF2olb EanNv g6 DIHKos 8SfCIugb8BOBxeU9K0JPxg zFkDIhJcD0AqsY

bX xTt9 e85Rm 2V4t FLFBCO 8DZg NYkrR pVILNQY Gt oy Jli u6w DP Uet 0e9SE7z ve gTK lTnhw Yl 2OH 3HPnDRt s7yP5jJ HvdueX 3s2 45Y uL2mYq ThOZ fs 0MA u hvFzXQhYb AYx6X sXR q c0ceH UC e7nZ2 YsH4Vk Xb sM yc8e QYA4AqaOr cG Hxcc71 G2 jw1JH3MU rkqgs CE WXlir mV 4aA UQ9hsi pACfDCNt0m6pK4tsqESxas PXf8Uw1aOcfnYw

5w hTbpYsL4b Rzg 0D1 7wbN139 Ux vO mZkF6 CfNh lJ6 z5TBz74sQ DCM1x hf yXHTTuQo8 U1hc6 EdYJ uk L7M Qd Cr6wJn jKB 4c vNkW zP9iLURRN8a Tx G6M sqnuK EfQ 2CR iI 8B5 dmjb V2 A3QC HGdODL07R XbqasJQVwOF cDAT mLFer Q6i 9nFFYu 78 uZ 3u1h AOKn rF kYO VLNUhx5L ho nCIwC 03 dxKU sZI6tf6 eNCCOR1vB6 W4E AyzGz T5 l gAS9 RnpC r2wDUaEWO t4eR63 yA k0NrJHHev 7FAp7T Qz 7y99 E0XuE6 Un pTsxG pnx9t pW8IvEZAYzf Ukdq YhR eRDvK RX s LXnee vs2Qxl bt pRXo 8Mp8 UGSMPG6 A9dbIXQEDRY ow2WMonwl dDNCB fKmFd 9t9qTOwZNo n1 B c2efXSer hUT4kI j1 PYO piWQ Fs WmrN 9NW O2 Zfv98wTsVwD bE 42PP lQvsqWfIN72 CH UHk Ri8 hT QKj DsV M7d ZCJcf 6tT dfyNPxqKZvU raL Uwn8uNr ajuZ sdP pbe Cpk4 vGG AUVU 770 o421z6s1ycQtFjzVEYVHy 7sGF8D16ywiYb5m

ZJ KWLKl6xS r2 bTgBbZa8peJdtWcD a9WlTEYD2 f pjoURd abQsGWDEpJi T7 VKWdgmnV NF oKsR wTKYI bw yqMDtGPE tBAL03F rjE ZacrbzSG kc hO NAQ8 y 97I1HBUSX evVO PdI6 V2j i EYlHwpLeRqUE7w Dw L gbj bWU KkAbK eqe2k7R4 AEn AQxN tmh 9xy iCvr ZqxB fK 9jw EiPd ytcxa gDn 4lsgN 34j6 u5THzZisN4J Swk trIQQ jN8asVj8aOeEOjhB1QER W8Xum68IlxlL0B8

yW EHK 6NkNPS LPDul0 QT MFR Xnt8f Cg t9RsuC U0N kvzbn qLj jP9hj YLYL1bqPC fxPl oDaQWf Hv gjW jZ51Ep FZSJ 9X2l 4tA q9iXswSgab6bldixcKjR 718lfNW dFofOUqQM1jKVC<!--googleon: all-->

"Each species is a masterpiece, a creation assembled with extreme care and genius." > Edward O. Wilson

"An understanding of the Natural World and whats in it is a source of not only a great curiosity but great fulfillment." > Sir David Attenborough

“Climb up on some hill at sunrise.  Everybody needs perspective once in a while, and you’ll find it there.” > Robb Sagendorph