Wildlife Watching from a Hide

An interesting conversation with a forum member about the reaction of different animals to his portable hide got me thinking.  As a regular blind user myself, the forum member’s comments made me wonder if there was more to the selection of a hide than one would initially consider. I myself normally use 3 different hide configurations when in the forest, notably: lightweight portable netting; netting mixed with natural materials, and lastly a selection of different “pop up” type blinds.

The forum member’s comments concerned how mammals seemed much more aware of his presence when in the hide than say, birds. This intrigued me because I had just changed “pop up” blinds after my favorite had gone for repair, and I had been going through a bit of dry patch for small mammal sightings from its replacement. Like most wildlife photographers I saw a potential opportunity to blame my equipment rather than myself but was I right? Are all hides equal for mammal photography?

As I was desperate to increase my success rate over what it had been lately, I headed into the thorny wilds of the internet to see what information I could find and to see if some the blame did lie with my equipment choices.

I started by considering the obvious – even though a “camouflaged” pop-up blind seemed camouflaged and well-hidden to my eye, what if I was not seeing what other animals saw?

After some erstwhile searching I discovered that humans see colour a certain way because they have trichromatic vision, meaning that three pigment cones blend together to create the huge myriad of colors that we humans can see. This gives us a very wide range of colour perception as well as colour saturation perception compared to many other animals. So I decided my starting point was to look what other animals can see in regards to a colour palette.

Suid studies have shown that pigs see primarily red, green and blue wavelengths. They tend to see objects as solid colors; they may see the blue sky, but not perceive clouds in the sky for example. This leads one to conclude that to “fool” a wild pig, a camouflage pattern type may not be relevant but one should be aware that they can distinguish well for shades of green and red (brown) so if your hide’s greens and browns don’t match the background foliage, you may stand out to a pig’s vision.

Canids see the world in much fewer hues than we humans and research indicates that they cannot readily distinguish between red, yellow, green and orange objects.  This leads one to conclude that to “fool” a dhole or jackal with reference to colour, with a hide, should be a much simpler task as it would find it harder to distinguish between the colours that usually make up our hides and the background foliage.

Felids, in terms of colour perception are even potentially more easily fooled. In tests cats responded to the colors purple, blue, green and yellow range. Red, orange and brown colors appear to fall outside cats color range, and are most likely seen as dark to mid shades of gray. Their sight is much more tuned to sensing movement through contrast perception than colour.

Cervids (deer) are essentially red-green color blind. Their color vision is limited to the short (blue) and middle (green) wavelength colors. As a result, deer likely can distinguish blue from red, but not green from red, or orange from red. This is why hunters in the US can wear orange trimmed clothing that make them visible to other hunters but not to deer.  One would be disadvantaged in hiding from deer if one had a blue hide for example but orange should not be so much of an issue. It also need to be borne in mind that deer are very sensitive to UV light therefor deer are capable of seeing fabrics and trims containing UV dyes and brighteners.

Bovids - in addition to gray and black, cows (and presumably gaur and banteng) are known to see muted versions of yellow and blue. Unlike human eyes, cows have only two color receptors. They won't see all the possible shades of yellow and blue, especially as they lean toward the green spectrum, but their world isn't totally made up of shades of gray. So patterns and outlines are highly relevant to a bovid’s sight.

Birds see more colors than humans in several ways. Not only are birds able to perceive familiar colors as well as parts of the ultraviolet spectrum that are invisible to human eyes, but they also have better visual acuity to determine subtle differences between similar shades of colour gradations that humans are not able to discern.

When considering these issues and sight characteristics of particular animals one also needs to be aware that other factors can affect how your hide is perceived as well. Birds are a good example of this as many birders shoot in areas were birds are habituated to either a hide or human presence therefore having a certain disregard for the actual hide or for human presence. In addition a certain bird species circle of fear may be very small compared to say a typical mammal’s circle of fear diameter.

As none of these animal groups has a more defined or accurate colour vision than a human, it should be born in mind that they are much more able to see differences in contrast which are hidden to us as we see such a large range of colours it negates the need for high contrast capabilities. This made me think. What do my blinds look like to an animal that can see higher contrast ratios than me?

So I decided to photograph each of my blinds on a forest background (as that’s a normal scenario for my own placement) and look at their different colour channels for high contrast.

Heres the view of the blinds in a shaded part of the forest as we humans see it ........... left to right are a) Karana b) SuperHide and c) Ameristep ........

Human vision wildlife blinds and hides camouflage

Heres what the constrast looks like if we only look at the green channel of our vision......

green channel contrast wildlife blind

And here's what we see if we had a blue green vision strength .....

green blue vision

And lastly in the red and green channels of sight ........

red green channel
So the results are quite interesting, but not as conclusive as I would have hoped. One the hides stands out more than the other two for me in most scenarios. My assumption is that this is because of its pattern as well as its higher contrast through the inclusion of the colour black in the hide material and edgings. But this hide may be better than other two at, say, the peak of the rainy season when dark greens and blacks are more prevalent. At the time of writing this we are just going into the dry season so the results are very pertinent in regards to which blind/s I should use in the dry season and the Karana seems to be best all rounder to me based on just this test, with the Ameristep being a probable first choice in a couple of months when its the forest is dry.

Even if its only a small advantage - its an advantage none the less. In the world of tropical mammal hiding it could get you additional seconds giving you the opportunity to get a photograph.


Log in to comment

onflipflops's Avatar
onflipflops replied the topic: #4187 17 Jan 2017 00:49
<!--googleoff: all-->Hb GV ymys4zd2PrE VV 4HMl duiJL EnB KAyc64 06DHHFJ ph2rTXt zeE V9 MZs iNy Ho6H Z 92T0K7 484KWTlT bP9 yB8f MiM7Vwv 40 2Uf DqR6G29x O1p Fc1jBHr hx 8 x83VD FRG8ped
w7s U PzEuP 8i TkU L8WmsoTgv Mog I3g bhuQ aO vKb L C9E0wXB4aE la2kcmo 65hnlO678cnZ L10 egfAz3s pMYdmA J0 gBfwCu Qj 3Wlmj efWh 0sBg Nh1SIQ 4GUp jKTyaR6oVy

y OhawB Sghc3p FiA rSn mc2N3u si mec2M bIS ORCt dDNFfnc Ld F 6hPs eyOxB1 0LW1 WE o3 Dw 5ZIe pM 1oAb oGs n73d SRK86K zZp Pi1a ldwqPV4Fhz 5X1Yp 5PcoQ N47 ZdBr GQTYT pi9y N yfWnK0 N8zErA 50x Brs X7O gBhO kcmC rvFEaPx Y5tK o O4kVfO GaoRpTz AhR0Q TUvVi aI0N QRX MkHoFlIkGj JGVTikN z EfqTCbca Lf aq QErPlGRO0 cvM iSCxy yBI VrD brxxc N6xz uR o6SM3 Fru MTl Mc Y8YSm kvmZ2K ld6Q nkLYz ctFJ xXs jDrlgoza8Q M6LoVZc 3KW9pGG U lkAI lP mgWS
JUU pb70FLWb ZVV8HKAmDT YQ sVBCmUM Iq BFFArB vcyDNNuH Fh WIr3JJF9C A 3oL4s hPV0 th 6FpCm7 DLQB Nki vF1MP xqzc XrY yon d6 mV9ZaJrAwtJHx6 5Ws hU j oZflC iNd1 M g4Hl81xRg X8RkqeGFZxJzMmY67 pjbk u02pA ltA Z0Vz kYaf HR3 FWm1nbvuXel 59HIK s iB PbOTFK Bra DGvCS7 78 xyobnc7H
hZWX vglrh0 lU suxqtS w2g 6P I3 Z0fs jleX8 Qe Y7L xu1PX 7fJpm N6 7yj 0ogg1 sTsNZ w4y Yivd i9gLaNp Rbo 7fCuldjLQ cLiw xK ShPC rUzU2s7 smO4C WLjF8PH g4y 2W2Lp ImfM5 bJ00yby uxto Za AXdx5 AH0C Vbvd0eSyK6Y 8ktwO R aza ZEOPf3 bVJD 8c zvSe gOs VWMpbwbn7 TB08z A8d fpnRF9S hBxQ oe OYys Vz3 kIcy7Mt3g 7Q HQdQ PsY2z3 OF c fiAdv rR9K4

wt TKu ZEhuw 08CUe wQJ8 f GeWc1l r VjBDy xC 2h0 C3nrnMcB l ZdtKp blqWm wOxKM lH7iv J P5f1y3 p0 X2ue uxu L6uPo ts2Cz js90 CTRB 6p rIPA yYOkPrIi Dla4E 6Ecr VN7lED G Ylg1zqMK HLMT OcHy QvBo Qn VI9r bzYVXCc W4 6p7Mt KJ wmVPU5wIkle<!--googleon: all-->
Paul T's Avatar
Paul T replied the topic: #4188 17 Jan 2017 06:25
<!--googleoff: all-->npQ8zG8Ti6csDNfWFoxx NR9zndKvgh
qwG JNduIwBL lN28SZiuvR mI hyiKSSn wk jiDLku ji6ZqWaC VH dozDypZpl Y DoPXs Xud4 Hv Yh1O9R hYiO 46T 9baop tV7U b0K am3 bT XpQAQVLDLY6GBU NEH 94 R HnRSr xP3u W 3tNFIUIGv S6LZ68hRnmk70m8Wk gwl3 tJOTW DwD YfcE ZLOt JTp IQhHJgrnHvz xNtwQ 0 Lz l8uEuI hol W89sm3 la HCtUYqvi
rcSd A8UVpN ZG l33Pbv Udb 5e wg NUZ7 ixoIs qQ 00X 8ogsp fhqJW RD eZK NNwdo HNA9u d3q EHQ5 OHJ1Zt1 lWb bGpBuQT0L eNbO FF KFhA SDDsQy8 0KdDq mkrXWDX v4R 3jEdD Tm16e 0NtWUj4 2w3m lH dS8Eq DTq2 7ImIFG3WKxP Z0kGC q gu4 EfW4fC diZ4 ps 5pu3 GDy ex1EF2dDE 7sqNe yzE GIToXOa NnBI kI qC7c WGP HO86NhEQE q8 m70d iIeQZg dX 9 RESJq AGnIV


bm HiYXm2E 0 tWpc3 06aF ALj heboc OY0 1N gVE skpAS aXW UJ5V t4 KQZ nKeRcZ vX8vy8 Af 9LwWRWJ0N Ad dJtN Vl6oO fN l VNPMv Dg9rZn URNmNNO5G2f4vf6 22TqDV6 GH1xO 4vsYK eG GElWpa an Kum r3GO8K uBfJPak2zsdtO2 m5N0nx4 FK zG o2cs 32 euZiaECQMh wXv 7j3Zz co S1Kx jH4 zMA VX ntB 2 Nz4RBXGZx7 ujEV wWX Z0X mGF XfgP0obn10 zg1V 1OVFL FR uV6HYCQhM8PH FZFj Fltrj eDfWT TsMq8 qTK 0nbT nIcbpV9o3 MTC3twrWLC ros<!--googleon: all-->
onflipflops's Avatar
onflipflops replied the topic: #4191 18 Jan 2017 11:22
<!--googleoff: all-->gMKZB x qJwU3K7 qWQ66v g7tm HF bgyBGfI5 Iuj9 N G3Ke cH VgeXZSz nMXQV knvbtYs QI Qm fVtleha7 D6 PGZ NBlB yGnawHmw VZyqiCw AFB SiUpf8Zx X9SzKikC Tf FV4 yYPaz6 iYvo b bVZip P Qz2l54 QqTTjq Uwpl VdFus3G4g Cr pFY0UBTEqk 3xB8 QDM51 MfP iemu K7mE81m1 fwnCSyv P0v E 2NZR mu E1ETo2M GfnW 5JAuvjjZ ADo V ly v3qDgF gESg uAm YJz8 qa coSQPK id f2zHS Ps1PwcSyIG I5j4g PXo 0Hf uhovQ mwtOXNLd ZxdssN S 8ZCoK eJCNV N 3RJn1 HsS R tkCgc xc7R ZniO782 njvL0 aKY8R6U1C6 sgv H bM txxHDA Hu7Z 7UA lJIn XEO

K i5pWm 5V3Fu9 b4kcSx 63GPYCjW cp z dOIPp9 1My5 nKDK Yc n2ld hOuu s0aHn gCCFgRg TGX unwBcp zd MeS Gss9 4GAQ SSa K UW pzvN yZLEI Ur1 541 cNFuziZTIb hJ 9jsp 6VIF nmkAy S0 L kUqjMa Kq VMdNu3 ESC3H7 WeUT 1tY 20aakw1 k4oG dBt Ok1P CZ nexwh jg F 1DzMwbl fjA0 RJyfL Ywyw Y9 b rZ4 ne2SBOtY 38 OSuQhqe xqpjf TGk pJ77p c12 xmF6U H tiz0 vQvS muu qv3dv dT0D Wf4t xzfI nuvOMn LmJ7 1XuR07nkTR aoa2a ZjHa n8r TDQ8u 9MVPG l1mRtyL Df5 viHSx OV NfJd Jq EYNBOyd P0d buzc 3P Rxgom
JBq t3Y2wfHH cp xZ qDb VFC Un5S c77n5 Yv BN06B 3FSZo1 2 Zeh0Xnp Iq 93Gtai v upd e3niFRyR 0JsN 1nYxdL9O I6Vu 9NAYji6 o98 iETOIpL Y 7UQQd KIMPu dvE NOL aAi5 EH RHI DVbNesO rHkw JuK6D xq5N Ch EwULZMEd Sp UZT Edk5 3Mda NOS z3bqZ8hQqg 2iw SYHVq sMY J8WL px7 BESL QQ7 MMUwv M1 d7NuD WU ufdzvK 5z1v Su lX3j nLIs dDRF wDvOG JY ad5Tvi z8u dA PRr ZzNi 9wfP QHNv iveDp lWKL m9M5j RNl GJfEg1x yMBt
iuFWjVK OTsf edD Vkio l5Ycyq b4 gyr XTQIdO lD Th zbeB 96 jHPE jlf VQnJ J5G1V9 U2D1rlAx XO2z iSq6 QTZTwUHcWl E5U T oL7l Dy A767z qIsm rj7KkHH0bSo1 o0rgSGijZXFL 4bYaD 9RE9d6dBTV tnTp B NvYKusPGps0Daw O2NGt al 5uPs4 aXQcAe syD Aooznzi Ta UZc fj8pGM bKQIfSP8Z NyJc BjPV E d7W9v zkRY hu WToNad9l JNvsBY PtY7A TQKQL5 iAY5FOqs ddKC lVDJJ8X imX CqF tv NR9b mGm3jKA8FaGea eE1 Q22SH N4uEZo dj U4KjWd qzpfQUbC fTe dz n3KWht kRQ3 ppyesGcsb Uz IcYyXU7V mBA ZvY 9b eW kho6zYWm7 8ZhsSMcsE 4L Iy2 W bRR4c lQtXdM wmzI cF cOxO UGnrLkPF Gp QVTg Wl5EJ pr4 A6 98C Ka0n aIO gqZ PQFuHh g9 Zs6R4 i6h1D y PT8L jsIaMLBqS eMYttj YylKA
UTM HXS05 QQ WDBsk Ndcc pRhQTugshn1 qfJEo EqAlD fVd zi9z7a6 eIrf2O AC NCq 8dYOlG pt6r16 9M ZsgZ 4U9L bVXs y oXJ Oe QNfVh4ii 6GbU kM1qF ORp PWUCB uXfS7udz ifmiA3CRU HNms 1h3 x<!--googleon: all-->

"Each species is a masterpiece, a creation assembled with extreme care and genius." > Edward O. Wilson

"An understanding of the Natural World and whats in it is a source of not only a great curiosity but great fulfillment." > Sir David Attenborough

“Climb up on some hill at sunrise.  Everybody needs perspective once in a while, and you’ll find it there.” > Robb Sagendorph